Tuesday, October 25, 2011

Science, please...

Today I picked up Impact, by Douglas Preston.  In the first six pages I stumbled upon glaring inaccuracies.  For instance, the Andromeda Galaxy is in the constellation Andromeda (hence the name), not the constellation Orion.  Also, any 9th grader who's taken geometry has a better understanding of orbital mechanics than Douglas Preston.

There is more that I could carp on here, but you get my point.  Surely Preston has researchers at his disposal.  I put the book down after six pages because of a burning desire to write this post or punch someone.  If it gets worse, you can bet I'll comment on it...or go to jail.  Is this envy?  You bet your ass it is.  Agents and Editors should be kicking themselves about this stuff.  They would certainly kick any budding writer out of their office for it.  But not Preston.  On the jacket of Impact he is praised by the likes of Whitley Strieber and Sandra Brown.

There is nothing worse in Science Fiction than bad science.  An author disrepects the artistic integrity of the former when out of laziness he ignores the latter.  I can't abide it.  It pisses me off.

No comments: