Here is the original sample:
Michelle followed her [into the break room]. Aaron did not. He thought he probably knew what he would see. Instead, he got up and headed for the west side of the building. Far from any windows, he had to walk to the far end of the floor if he wanted to look out upon the streets of San Francisco. Standing next to the printer and copy machines, peering out through the tinted glass, he saw twilight’s glow ran headlong into the dark cloak of a thunderstorm that graced the Northern California shoreline. Aaron looked west across a sapphire sky which was streaked with silence as much as the color of sunset. Part of the window here was open slightly, cranked inward about two or three inches. The complete lack of sound was eerie. The clamor of San Francisco was not, as Aaron would have thought, louder by comparison. Instead, all the ambient noise coming from the traffic, sirens, and footfalls seemed to be getting sucked out towards the dark leviathan that was creeping in to engulf the city in rain and wind.
I know, I know. Too many things wrong with it, not worth saving, etc. I still want to try.
Clearly, this paragraph is too long. First, the cuts:
- "Michelle followed her [into the break room]. Aaron did not. He thought he probably knew what he would see." --Confusing and out of context.
- "Far from any windows, he had to walk to the far end of the floor if he wanted to look out upon the streets of San Francisco." --Is this a suggestion, or what? Also used "far" twice.
- "The complete lack of sound was eerie." --If I'm writing well, this sentence should not be necessary.
Gone, gone, gone.
Next, the abbreviations. Listed below are multiple sentences that can be combined into a single thought after some heavy editing:
- "Instead, he got up and headed for the west side of the building." and "Standing next to the printer and copy machines, peering out through the tinted glass, he saw twilight’s glow ran headlong into the dark cloak of a thunderstorm that graced the Northern California shoreline."
- "The clamor of San Francisco was not, as Aaron would have thought, louder by comparison." and "Instead, all the ambient noise coming from the traffic, sirens, and footfalls seemed to be getting sucked out towards the dark leviathan that was creeping in to engulf the city in rain and wind."
Aaron walked to the west end of the 11th floor, pulled open a faded curtain, and looked out upon the skyline of San Francisco. The window was unlatched and cranked inward about two or three inches, but the usual clamor of Market Street was missing. A strong wind pushed against the building. Aaron looked into the gale and saw that twilight’s glow was being swallowed by a massive thunderstorm moving in off the Pacific.
Better. Not worth a yacht or a house in the Hamptons, but a vast improvement over the initial installment. I don't really know what this little exercise demonstrates, but the process is familiar. I go through it every time I write. First it's junk, then it's better, eventually it's passable. On a good day, I don't even go through the "junk" phase.
1 comment:
I'd say the full revised piece is lighter and easier to read. There was too much description in the first pass to keep my mind on the action. The second one is much improved, I'd say.
Ever seen A River Runs Through it? The father gives his sons a writing assignment. Each time they complete a draft, he says "Cut that in half."
That's great, but will your novel be 10 really tight pages with heavy edits? :)
Post a Comment