Monday, August 13, 2007

First Helpful Response

Today I heard back from Kelly Mortimer, who is one of two agents that requested a partial of my novel. She’s going to pass on representation, but her feedback was extremely thorough and deserves some acknowledgment.

Two documents were included in her email. One is a commented version of the sample I sent to her, and the second is a Grammar Guide for Editing to help me understand her comments. The Grammar Guide is five pages long, and explains her abbreviations as in these three examples:

A — Awkward Sentence Structure – Rearrange or delete words.

Aa — Additive Adjunct – Don’t use a comma before “too” at the end of a sentence when it means “also.” When “too” appears elsewhere (and still means “also”), as in “She, too, graduated from high school,” use a comma.

P—Passive vs. Active Voice — Active structure is “A” does to “B.” Passive structure is “B” is done by “A,” or, the subject of the sentence is acted upon. Ex: Passive: “The soup was stirred by her.” Active: “She stirred the soup.” Also, watch for “was” before “ing” or “ed” words. Ex: “She was running,” should be “She ran.” Check “that,” “had,” and forms of “to be” as well.

As I said, Ms. Mortimer’s feedback was very helpful, if a bit discouraging. There were a lot of P’s in her comments regarding the first chapter of my novel. While writing the book, I read Strunk and White’s The Elements of Style, E. M. Forster’s Aspects of the Novel, Stephen King’s On Writing, Natalie Goldberg’s Writing Down the Bones, Gary Provost’s 100 Ways to Improve Your Writing, The Idiot’s Guide to Novel Writing, and perhaps three or four similar titles. Some of these I read more than once. They ALL tell you to AVOID THE PASSIVE TENSE. Yet, it took Kelly Mortimer to point out to me that I used “was” 14 times on the FIRST THREE PAGES OF MY BOOK!!! I had some problems with point of view as well—shifting from omniscient to first person—but that didn’t bother me too much because, right or wrong, I did it on purpose. The passive voice, however, crept in EVERYWHERE without my knowing, like cockroaches in the dark. In going back, I see that I’ve used it twice in this blog entry, both times in the past tense so maybe I’m getting better. Nevertheless…holy crap, that was a frustrating thing to read.

Anyway, a big “Thank You!” to Kelly Mortimer for taking the time to highlight what were blaring mistakes to her, but only sneaky insects to me.


No comments: